3955 W. New Haven Avenue West Melbourne, FL. 32904

    ▸ Celebrated Sandwiches

monte cristo sandwich

World Famous Monte Cristo

Honey wheatberry bread ... layered with tender ham, roasted turkey, Swiss and American cheeses. Batter-dipped, gently fried, and coated with powdered sugar. Served with red raspberry preserves for dipping.

chicken wrap

Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Wrap

Chicken tenders, lettuce, tomatoes, Colby cheese, and bacon ... wrapped in a flour tortilla with our special smoky Honey Dijon dressing. ALSO available with grilled chicken, for a minor upcharge.

turkey o'toole sandwich

Turkey O’Toole™

Freshly sliced turkey breast, melted Swiss cheese, and our special smoky honey Dijon dressing. Served on a pretzel bun.

reuben sandwich

The Classic Reuben

An Irish favorite and Bennigan's specialty. Sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, 1000 Island dressing, and served on Rye bread.

monte cristo sandwich and soup

Half World Famous Monte Cristo with Soup or Salad

Great for a quick lunch ... Half of a Monte Cristo sandwich ... plus a crock of soup or a salad (Garden or Caesar).

club sandwich

Bennigan’s Club™

Honey wheat bread, toasted and seasoned with freshly made basil mayonnaise. Layered with tender ham, roasted turkey, bacon, tomato, shredded lettuce, Swiss, and Cheddar cheeses.

french dip sandwich

The Original Irish Dip

Succulent roast beef with a layer of caramelized onions on a toasted garlic roll. Served with Bennigan’s au jus and sour cream horseradish sauce.

cajun chicken o'toole

Cajun Chicken O’Toole

Blackened grilled chicken breast, bacon, melted Swiss cheese, and our special smoky Honey Dijon dressing. Served on a pretzel bun.

club sandwich and soup

Half Bennigan’s Club™ with Soup or Salad

Great for a quick lunch ... Half of a Bennigan’s Club ... plus a crock of soup or a side salad (Garden or Caesar).

crispy chicken sandwich

Lina’s Crispy Chicken Sandwich

This crispy chicken sandwich is a show stopper -- A tender chicken breast, hand-breaded, then gently fried to golden perfection. Topped with Pepper Jack cheese, drizzled with our spicy Sriracha Aioli PLUS topped with our Bennigan's kicked-up coleslaw and tossed in Lina’s secret sweet and spicy sauce.

Our Celebrated Sandwiches in Melbourne FL are to die for! Whether it is the Bennigan’s Club, our World Famous Monte’ Cristo, or the Classic Reuben, we certainly have you covered. Every Sandwich is served with our Homestyle French fries seasoned with Sea Salt. Add a side Caesar or garden salad or crock of soup for an additional cost.


*Beef served rare or medium-rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon customer request. Consuming undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness.


** Food Allergens – We use a variety of items in our food products – Including, but not limited to the following items: Peanuts, various Nuts, Soybeans, Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Fish, Shellfish, and others. Even if not listed… If you have allergies, please inform your server before ordering. Occasionally products may come in contact with these or other ingredients.